House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ed Royce Urges Census Bureau To Add “Taiwanese” Check-Off Box In Census 2020 Form

In a letter dated October 27 (Attached), chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee Ed Royce (R-CA) urged the United States Census Bureau to add a separate “Taiwanese” check-off box in the Census 2020.

Royce writes: “In 1997, the State Department expressed concern about listing “Taiwanese” as a race in the Census questionnaire because it “would be contrary to U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interests.” However, as the Census is a purely domestic policy matter, it should not be subject to international politics and diplomatic pressure.”

Royce concludes: “The Census Bureau must ensure that the 2020 Census is both accurate and reflective of the U.S. population. As Taiwanese-Americans consider themselves a separate ethnicity from Chinese Americans, I believe that it would be prudent to honor and respect their identity… I thank you for your attention to this matter and urge you to give this designation its full and fair consideration.”

FAPA started this campaign for a separate check off box under the race question before the 2000 Census. Then FAPA President Wen-yen Chen appeared as a witness to a congressional hearing before the Subcommittee on the Census in 1998. However, FAPA was informed by the Census Bureau at the time that a 1997 State Department memorandum stipulated that the “listing of “Taiwanese” as a race in a Census questionnaire would inevitably raise sensitive political questions…contrary to the U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interest.”

Over the years, many Taiwanese American organizations campaigned for a “Taiwanese” check-off box. In 2008, the Taiwanese American Citizens League made a video starring prominent Taiwanese Americans, calling for the same.

So, still today, there are severe discrepancies between Federal Agencies when counting the Taiwanese American population. According to the 2010 Census, the population of Taiwanese Americans was 230,382. However; according to 2014 Homeland Security data on Lawful Permanent Residents, the Taiwanese American population accumulated from 1950 to 2010 was 450,673.

FAPA President Peter Chen reacts: “We believe that the demographic count from the Census Bureau is a purely domestic American affair, and should not fall victim to international politics. The U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service already maintains a separate quota for Taiwanese immigrants coming to the United States. So a fear of Chinese reprisals should not be an excuse for the Census Bureau to not facilitate a fair count of the Taiwanese American population.”

Peter Chen adds: “The current policy of the Census Bureau to exclude a Taiwanese check off box is solely a U.S. self-imposed restriction. We must have accurate data on how many Taiwanese Americans there are today. There should be no outside political influence preventing the United States to count us. We want to be counted!”

Peter Chen concludes: “FAPA thanks the effort of the entire Taiwanese American community on this very important issue.”

美國眾議院外交委員會主席羅伊斯要求人口普查局在2020的人口普查表上將「台灣人」列入正式選項

在10月27日，眾議院外交委員會主席羅伊斯(R-CA)致函要求人口普查局在2020的人口普查表上將「台灣人」列入正式選項。

羅伊斯寫到: “在1997年，國務院對在人口普查表族群問題下加入「台灣人」表示憂慮，認為這與美國政府的政策及美國國家利益是背道而馳的。但是人口普查是一個純美國內政事務，不應該是國際政治施展壓力的對象。

羅伊斯提到: 人口普查局必須確認2020年的人口普查是準確也真實地反映出美國的人口。既然台美人認為他們與中美人是不一樣的族群，我相信尊重他們的自我認同的身分才是謹慎及有尊嚴的作法。我感謝普查局對這件事的關注，同時也要求對這一個完整及公平的考慮。

前FAPA會長陳文彥，在1998年曾受國會眾議院的人口委員會的聽證會邀請，以證人身份出席。但是FAPA後來被人口普查局告知，國務院已在在1997年的便籤中裁示，「在人口普查表上列出台灣人的選項，最終將引起敏感的政治問題…這與美國政府的政策及美國國家利益則是背道而馳的。」

然而過去多年來，有許多台美團體持續推廣在人口調查表族群問題下，加入另台灣人的選項。例如在2008年，台美公民協會(Taiwanese American Citizens League)特別製作一個影片來推廣這個議題，影片中則包含了眾多知名的台美人

所以至今，當聯邦政府的各單位在計算台美人口時，這些單位的數據本身已經有很大的差別了。根據2010年的人口普查中，台美人口數為230,328。但是根據國安局在合法永久居留者的數據裡，從1950年至2010年的台美人已高達450,673。

FAPA會長陳正義則認為:「我們相信人口普查局的人口數據是一個純美國內政事務，而不應該向國際政治屈服。」尤其現階段的美國移民局已經為移民至美國的台灣人特別設置配額。人口普查局不應該以畏懼中國打壓作為不執行準確計算台美人口數據的理由。

陳正義會長還說：「人口普查局目前在普查表上排除台灣人選項的政策，是一個自我設限的規定。我們需要有一個正確算出最正確台美人的數據。不應該有任何外在的政治因素來阻止美國來得到這個數據。台美人要求被列入選項和尊重! 」

陳正義會長提到: 「台灣人公共事務會為這個議題在此感謝台美社區全體同仁之付出。」

Chairman Royce Pushes for Taiwanese American Census Inclusion

Washington, D.C. –  U.S. Representative Ed Royce (R-Fullerton), Chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, has written U.S. Census Bureau Director John H. Thompson to request the addition of a Taiwanese identification option for Americans participating in the Census.

“As Taiwanese Americans consider themselves a separate ethnicity from Chinese Americans, I believe that it would be prudent to honor and respect their identity through adding a Taiwanese descent option to the Census,” said Chairman Royce. “As the Census is a purely domestic policy matter, it should not be subject to international politics and diplomatic pressure.”

In 1997, the U.S. State Department expressed concern about listing “Taiwanese” as a race in the Census questionnaire because it “would be contrary to U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interests.”

Chairman Ed Royce represents California’s 39th Congressional District, home to one of the nation’s largest Taiwanese American communities.

Text of the letter

Mr. John H. Thompson
Director
United States Census Bureau
4600 Silver Hill Road
Washington, DC 20233

Dear Director Thompson:

I am writing on behalf of my constituents who would like to see the United States Census Bureau include a separate check box for Americans who identify as “Taiwanese” in sections that deal with race in the 2020 Census questionnaire.

In 1997, the State Department expressed concern about listing “Taiwanese” as a race in the Census questionnaire because it “would be contrary to U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interests.” However, as the Census is a purely domestic policy matter, it should not be subject to international politics and diplomatic pressure.

Many of my Taiwanese-American constituents have consistently expressed frustration and concern to me over the lack of statistics available on Taiwanese-Americans.

The Census Bureau must ensure that the 2020 Census is both accurate and reflective of the U.S. population. As Taiwanese-Americans consider themselves a separate ethnicity from Chinese Americans, I believe that it would be prudent to honor and respect their identity.

I thank you for your attention to this matter and urge you to give this designation its full and fair consideration.

Sincerely,

Ed Royce
Chairman, House Foreign Affairs Committee

Photo Credit: CSUF Photos (Flickr)

The post House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Ed Royce Urges Census Bureau To Add “Taiwanese” Check-Off Box In Census 2020 Form appeared first on Formosan Association for Public Affairs.

Taiwanese American Organizations Join Ranks To Be Counted In The 2020 Census

On August 12, 2016, the joint Taiwanese American Organizations sent a letter to the National Advisory Committee of the Census Bureau to request the Census Bureau that a check off box for “Taiwanese” be added under the race question (question six) on the Census 2020 form.

FAPA, who initiated this joint letter, started this campaign for a separate check off box under the race question as early as 1997, i.e. prior to Census 2000. Then FAPA President Wen-yen Chen appeared as a witness at a Congressional hearing before the Subcommittee on the Census in 1998. FAPA was informed at the time by the Census Bureau that a 1997 State Department memorandum stipulated that the “listing of “Taiwanese” as a race in a Census questionnaire would inevitably raise sensitive political questions…contrary to the U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interest.”

However, since the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service already maintains a separate quota for Taiwanese coming to the United States, the Taiwanese American Organizations feel that there should be no reason for the Census Bureau to continue this policy based on international political concerns.

In the letter, the joint Taiwanese American Organizations wrote: “Taiwanese Americans all over the country have expressed their concern and frustration to us about not knowing how many Taiwanese Americans there actually are in the U.S. today.”

There are severe discrepancies between Federal Agencies when counting the Taiwanese American population. According to the 2010 Census, the population of Taiwanese Americans was 230,382. However, according to the 2014 Homeland Security data on Lawful Permanent Residents, the Taiwanese American population accumulated from 1950 to 2010 was 450,673.

In this letter, the Organizations added: “We are shocked that our Census, which is a purely domestic affair, would fall victim to international politics. No foreign country should dictate how our own Census Bureau counts its citizens. Taiwanese Americans today recognize that they are a separate ethnicity from Chinese Americans and we must honor and respect that. The Census Bureau can no longer ignore this.”

FAPA President Peter Chen reacts: “The current policy of the Census Bureau to exclude a Taiwanese check off box is solely a U.S. self-imposed restriction. We want and must have accurate data on how many Taiwanese Americans there are today. There should be no outside political influence preventing the United States to count us. We want to be counted!”

Taiwanese Association of America President, Ming-hung Chow states: “This is not fair! Many smaller minorities can have their own check-off box while the Taiwanese don’t. We, the Taiwanese, are not receiving the recognition we deserve in the international community, we should be rightfully recognized in America, the country we call home.”

十二個台美人團體聯名信要求將「台灣人」正式列入2020全美人口普查選項中

八月十二日12個台美人團體一同聯署致函給人口調查局的全國建議委員會，正式要求在2020的人口普查調查表中，第六題族群問題應加入「台灣人」的選項。

台灣人公共事務會（FAPA）發起這封團體聯名信。早在1997年，也就是2000年的人口普查前就開始推廣在人口調查表族群問題下加入「台灣人」的選項。當時的FAPA會長陳文彥在1998年曾受國會眾議院的人口委員會的聽證會邀請，以證人身份出席。但是FAPA後來被人口調查局告知，國務院已在在1997年的便籤中裁示，「在人口調查表上列出台灣人的選項，最終將引起敏感的政治問題…這與美國政府的政策及美國國家利益則是背道而馳的。」

但是在現階段，美國移民局已經為移民至美國的台灣人特別設置配額，所以台美團體則認為人口調查局也不應該有任何以國際政治考量的原因下來繼續這項政策。 在這封信中，台美人團體也表示：「散佈在美國各地的台美人已為他們無法知道美國目前有多少台美人感到無奈與受挫。

台美人的人口數據在聯邦政府的單位裡已經有很大的差別了。根據2010年的人口普查中台美人口分為230,328。但是根據國安局在合法永久居留者的數據裡，從1950年至2010年的台美人已高達450,673。

在這封信中，這些團體提到：「我們很驚訝我們的人口調查局，個純美國內政事務竟然會向國際政治屈服。我們的人口調查局如何計算我們人民則不應該由任何國家來決定。今天的台美人都認為他們與華裔美國人是不同的族群，而當然我們也應當給予尊重人口調查局則不能再繼續的忽略此事。

FAPA會長陳正義在信中寫到：「人口調查局目前在普查表上排除台灣人選項的政策，是一個自我設限的規定。我們需要有一個正確算出最正確台美人的數據。而不應該有外在的政而不應該有外在的政治因素來阻止美國來計算這項數據。台美人要求被列入選項和尊重! 」

全美同鄉會會長周明宏表示：「這是不公平的! 許多比台灣更小的族群都有自己的選項但是台美人卻沒有。我們在國際並沒有得到我們應得的承認，但在美國，一個我們稱為家的國家則更理所當然地要被承認。」

Ms. Ditas Katague                             August 12, 2016
Chair, National Advisory Committee
U.S. Census Bureau
4600 Silver Hill Road Washington, DC 20233

Dear Ms. Katague:

We, the joint Taiwanese American organizations, write to you today to formally request that the National Advisory Committee recommends to the U.S. Census Bureau that a separate check-off box for “Taiwanese” be added under the race question (question six) on the Census 2020 form. We are pleased that over the years the Census form has evolved from excluding outsiders to including multiracialism.

However, we Taiwanese Americans have not been included in the Census form thus far. Taiwanese Americans all over the country have expressed their concern and frustration to us about not knowing how many Taiwanese Americans there actually are in the U.S. today.

We campaign for a separate check-off box for “Taiwanese” because Taiwanese Americans want to be counted! We have been campaigning for this since the mid-nineties. But we have thus far not been successful.

Why not? Because the Census Bureau was told by our State Department in a 1997 memo that: “We believe that any listing of “Taiwanese” as a race in a Census questionnaire would inevitably raise sensitive political questions because it could be misinterpreted as official U.S. recognition of Taiwanese as a racial category chat is separate from Chinese. This would be contrary to U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interests.

Therefore, our position is that it would be inappropriate to list “Taiwanese” as a category of race separate from Chinese in the Census questionnaire.” We are shocked that our Census, which is a purely domestic affair, would fall victim to international politics. No foreign country should dictate how our own Census Bureau counts its citizens.

Taiwanese Americans today recognize that they are a separate ethnicity from Chinese Americans and we must honor and respect that. According to the 2010 Census, the population of Taiwanese Americans was 230,382k. However, according to our 2014 Homeland Security data on Lawful Permanent Residents, the Taiwanese American population accumulated from 1950 to 2010 was 450,673.

Clearly, there are severe discrepancies between Federal Agencies when counting the Taiwanese American population.  The Census Bureau can no longer ignore this. That is why we are requesting that the Census Bureau create a separate check off box for Taiwanese Americans on the 2020 Census form under the race question (question six,) so that we will finally have accurate data on how many Taiwanese Americans there are in the United States today.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Sincerely,
Formosan Association for Public Affairs
Taiwanese Association of American
Dr. Chen Wen-Chen Memorial Foundation
Dr. Wang Kang-Lu Memorial Foundation
Formosan Association for Human Rights
North America Taiwanese Medical Association
North America Taiwanese Professors’ Association
North America Taiwanese Women’s Association
Taiwanese American Citizens League
Taiwanese American Historical Society
World Taiwanese Congress
World United Formosans for Independence – USA

台美人組織聯名信聯名名單

• 台灣人公共事務會
• 全美台灣同鄉會
• 陳文成教授紀念基金會
• 王康陸博士紀念基金會
• 全美台灣人權協會
• 北美洲台灣人醫師協會
• 北美洲台灣人教授協會
• 北美洲台灣婦女會
• 台美公民協會
• 台美人歷史協會
• 世界台灣人大會
• 台灣獨立建國聯盟美國本部

Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons

The post Taiwanese American Organizations Join Ranks To Be Counted In The 2020 Census appeared first on Formosan Association for Public Affairs.

FAPA: “Taiwanese Americans Want To Be Counted!”

In a letter to the National Advisory Committee of the Census Bureau dated June 21^st, 2016, FAPA President Peter Chen, formally requested the Census Bureau that a check off box for “Taiwanese” be added under the race question (question six) on the Census 2020 form.

FAPA started this campaign for a separate check off box under the race question before the 2000 Census. Then FAPA President Wen-yen Chen appeared as a witness to a congressional hearing before the Subcommittee on the Census in 1998. However, FAPA was informed by the Census Bureau that a 1997 State Department memorandum stipulated that the “listing of “Taiwanese” as a race in a Census questionnaire would inevitably raise sensitive political questions…contrary to the U.S. Government policy and U.S. national interest.”

In his letter, FAPA President Peter Chen wrote: “We believe however that the demographic count from the Census Bureau is a purely domestic American affair, and should not fall victim to international politics.”

This is especially true as the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service already maintains a separate quota for Taiwanese coming to the United States, there should be no reason for the Census Bureau to continue this policy based on international political concerns.

In his letter, Peter Chen added: “According to the Washington-based East-West Center, the Taiwanese American population in the 2000 Census was 144,795, while in the 2010 Census it was 230,382.¹ However, according to 2014 Homeland Security data on Lawful Permanent Residents, the Taiwanese American population accumulated between 1950 and 2014 to 472,222.² Therefore, we believe that a better total estimate of Taiwanese Americans today would be around 500,000. Clearly, there are severe discrepancies between Federal Agencies when counting the Taiwanese American population.  The Census Bureau can no longer ignore this.”

Peter Chen reacts: “The current policy of the Census Bureau to exclude a Taiwanese check off box is solely a U.S. self-imposed restriction. We want accurate data on how many Taiwanese Americans there are today. Nobody knows! This is unconscionable. We want to be counted!”

FAPA要求將「台灣人」列入正式選項

FAPA會長陳正義在6月21日致函給人口調查局的全國建議委員會，正式要求在2020的人口普查調查表中，第六題族群問題應加入「台灣人」的選項。

FAPA開始推廣在人口調查表族群問題下加入「台灣人」的選項要回溯到2000年的人口普查，當時的FAPA會長陳文彥在1998年曾受國會眾議院的人口委員會的聽證會邀請，以證人身份出席。但是FAPA後來被人口調查局告知，國務院已在在1997年的便籤中裁示，「在人口調查表上列出台灣人的選項，最終將引起敏感的政治問題…這與美國政府的政策及美國國家利益則是背道而馳的。」

FAPA會長陳正義在信中寫到:「我們相信人口調查局的人口數據是一個純美國內政事務，而不應該向國際政治屈服。」

以現階段美國移民局已經為移民至美國的台灣人特別設置配額的話，則不可否定以上論述的真實性。人口調查局也不應該有任何以國際政治考療的原因下來繼續這項政策。

在這封信中又說道：「根據位在華府的East-West Center，在2000年和2010年的人口普查中台美人口分為144,795及230,328。但是根據國安局在合法永久居留者的數據裡，從1950年至2014年的台美人已高達472,222。所以我們相信若要估計現今台美人的人口數的話應該是約在五十萬左右。很明顯的，台美人的人口數據在聯邦政府的單位裡已經有很大的差別了。人口調查局則不能再繼續的忽略此事。」

陳正義會長還說：「人口調查局目前在普查表上排除台灣人選項的政策，是一個自我設限的規定。我們需要有一個正確算出最正確台美人的數據。沒有任何人知道最新數據，這完全不合理。台美人要求被列入選項和尊重! 」

The post FAPA: “Taiwanese Americans Want To Be Counted!” appeared first on Formosan Association for Public Affairs.